Istituto di Economia Internazionale - Economic Sanctions: Disappointing Old Wine in New Bottles

Recent Articles

Read more about our latest published articles.

Review’s Archive

Corresponding Author:
Miroslav N. Jovanović, University of Geneva, Global Studies Institute, Dušan Sidjanski Centre of Excellence in European Studies, Switzerland

Economic Sanctions: Disappointing Old Wine in New Bottles

Volume 75 - Issue 4 - Papers in memoriam of Amedeo Amato, November 2022
(pp. 545-576)
JEL classification: E42; F13; F19; F33; F42; F51; F59; N44
Keywords: Sanctions; Gas; Russia; Dollar; De-Globalisation; Bretton Woods; Monetary System; Rouble

Abstract

Economic sanctions are back and high on the policy agenda. They are used as ‘bloodless’ policy instruments that replace ‘hard’ wars against countries that need to alter their behaviour. Sanctions come in various types and shapes. They can be introduced both by international organisations and by individual countries. The rate of their success compared to goals varies as it may be difficult to agree on the measure of success. Basically, moderate sanctions have a greater success than total ones. Still, there are suggestions for the increase of the effectiveness of sanctions: the objectives of sanctions need to be clear; target’s weaknesses need to be located; what are the target’s capacities to absorb hits and retaliate; sanctions need to be reviewed and fine-tuned; and there should be conditions for removing sanctions. The 2022 ‘total economic and financial war’ against Russia ends the dollar-based globalisation. A new de-dollarized Bretton Woods version 3.0 financial system emerges as many countries throughout the word fear that they may fall under similar sanctions in the future. Sanctions may also be used as a handy tool to shift public attention from much bigger national and structural problems which the governments do not tackle decisively. Economic sanctions create immediate costs in both the target country and the sanctions-imposing countries. The same sanctions also create great new opportunities for innovations in the medium- and long-term which ought to be considered and turn into profits.

Read the full article

Download the article in PDF format to read and print.

Bibliography

Astrasheuskaya, N. (2021), “Russia Starts to Sow Seeds of ‘Wheat Diplomacy’’’, Financial Times, September 2.

Basso, D. (2022), “France Continued to Deliver Russia Weapons after 2014 Embargo”, EURACTIV, March 15.

Beattie, A. (2022), “Germany’s Nord Stream 2 Decision Shows Sanctions on Russia haven’t Worked”, Financial Times, February 23.

Berner, R., S. Cecchetti and K. Schoenholtz (2022), “Russian Sanctions: Some Questions and Answers’, VOX, March 21.

Bremner, C. (2022), “Ten EU Countries Sold Kit to Russia Despite Sanctions”, The Times, April 23.

Chestney, N. (2022), “Putin Wants 'Unfriendly' Countries to Pay for Russian Gas in Roubles”, Reuters, March23.

Chorzempa, M. (2022), “Export Controls against Russia are Working - with the Help of China”, Peterson Institute for International Economics, June 27.

Colibasanu, A. (2022), “Russia and the First Economic World War”, Geopolitical Futures, April 11.

Escobar, P. (2022), “Follow the Money: how Russia will Bypass Western Economic Warfare”, The Cradle, March 1.

Felbermayr, G., A. Kirilakha, C. Syropoulos, E. Yalcin and Y. Yotov (2021), “The ‘Global Sanctions Data Base’: Mapping international sanction policies from 1950-2019”, VOX, May 18.

Fishman, E. and C. Miller (2022), “The Right Way to Sanction Russian Energy”, Foreign Affairs, May 17.

Fletcher, L., T. Stubbington, R. Smith and J. Rennison (2022), “Hedge Funds Search for Bargains in Russian and Ukrainian Bonds”, Financial Times, March 24.

Foy, H. (2022), “Western Powers Oppose Linking Ukraine Peace Talks to Sanctions Relief for Russia”, Financial Times, March 31.

Foy, H. and D. Sheppard (2020), “Why Russian Oil Groups are Well Positioned for a Price Crash”, Financial Times, March 30.

Gambrell, J. (2022), “Saudi Arabia puts 81 to death in its Largest Mass Execution”, Time, March 12.

Ghosh, J., R. Hausman, H. James and S-J. Wei (2022), “Will the Russia Sanctions Work?”, Project Syndicate, March 31.

Gotev, G. (2015), “Brussels blesses merger between Daimler and Russian Military Vehicle Producer”, EURACTIV, February 26.

Haass, R. (1998), “Economic Sanctions: Too much of a Bad Thing”, Brookings, June 1.

Harding, R. (2022), “Toppling the Dollar as Reserve Currency Risks Harmful Fragmentation”, Financial Times, March 10.

Hassan, J. (2022), “International Cat Federation Bans Russian Cats from Competitions”, The Washington Post, March 3.

Hudson, M. (2022), “The American Empire Self-Destructs”, The Unz Review, March 7.

Hufbauer, G. and M. Hogan (2022), “How Effective are Sanctions against Russia?”, Peterson Institute for International Economics, March 16.

Jenkins, S. (2021), “Sanctions are imposed by the sanctimonious, and achieve nothing”, The Guardian, May 27.

Jenkins, S. (2022), “Sanctions don’t Work – Serious Diplomacy is the only Way to Stop Putin”, The Guardian, February 28.

Jovanović, M. (2020), Evolutionary Economic Geography, Edward Elgar: Cheltenham.

Kuper, S. (2022), “Is the West’s Increased Defence Spending even Necessary?”, Financial Times, July 7.

Martin, C. (2021), ‘Economic Sanctions under International Law: A Guide for Canadian Policy’. Ottawa: Rideau Institute on International Affairs.

Masters, J. (2019), “What Are Economic Sanctions?”, Council on Foreign Relations, August 12.

McMaken, R. (2022), “Why sanctions don’t work, and why they mostly hurt ordinary people”, Mises Institute, September 9.

Medetsky, A., M. Campbell and Y. Fedorinova (2016), “Putin is Growing Organic Power one T-34 Tank-Tomato at a Time”, Bloomberg, June 7.

Morris, S. and O. Storbeck (2022), “Deutsche Bank’s Key Russian IT Unit Hangs in the Balance”, Financial Times, March 4.

Mulder, N. (2022), “Keynes Warned the World against using Economic Sanctions. His Alternative is Worth Considering”, The Guardian, January 20.

Münchau, W. (2022a), “A BRIC, Impenetrable to Sanctions”, EVRO Intelligence, March 13.

Münchau, W. (2022b), “After Pestilence and War comes Famine”, EVRO Intelligence, April 25.

Nephew, R. (2017), The Art of Sanctions: A View from the Field, Columbia University Press: New York.

Peksen, D. (2019), “When do Economic Sanctions Work Best?”, Center for New American Security, June 10.

Pisani-Ferry, J. (2022), “Will Russia or the West Win the Economic and Financial Battle?”, Project Syndicate, September 1.

Politi, J. and D. Brower (2022), “US Warns of Sanctions for Buyers that Flout Price Cap on Russian Oil”, Financial Times, September 10.

Rapoza, K. (2022), “Worst-Ever Russia Sanctions Set to Become a Business, Market Nightmare”, Forbes, February 28.

Skidelsky, R. (2021), “The Case against Economic Sanctions”, Project Syndicate, October 19.

Tett, G. (2022), “Using Russian Assets to Rebuild Ukraine won’t be Easy”, Financial Times, May 26.

van Bergeijk, P.A.G. (Ed.) (2021), Research Handbook on Economic Sanctions, Edward Elgar: Cheltenham, pp. 1-24.

Wolf, M. (2022a), “Russia’s War will Remake the World”, Financial Times, March 15.

Wolf, M. (2022b), “A New World of Currency Disorder Looms”, Financial Times, March 29.

Wolf, M. (2022c), “Cryptocurrencies are not the New Monetary System we Need”, Financial Times, July 5.

Zolotova, E. (2022), “Can Russia Withstand Western Sanctions?”, Geopolitical Futures,

March 6.

Recent Articles

Review’s Archive

Economic Sanctions: Disappointing Old Wine in New Bottles

Abstract

Read the full article

Bibliography

Register your account

Authors’ login

Institute for International Economics of the Genoa Chamber of Commerce

Institute for International Economics
of the Genoa Chamber of Commerce